Sign and Submit Evaluation to HQDA

Sign and Submit Evaluation to HQDA

Whether you are an ink-signed NCOER or an AER, you must ensure that the evaluation you submit to HQDA includes the full SSN of the person you are evaluating. This provides credibility during the evaluation process and enables you to confirm that the rated Soldier has received the evaluation report. Ink-signed OERs/NCOERs/AERs must include the … Read more

How to Use the Unlock Rater Profile Process

How to Use the Unlock Rater Profile Process

Using a Rater Profile Process is very important because it will enable you to ensure that the Ratings you are sending out are accurate. The reason why it is important is that if you don’t, your employees will end up getting a poor rating. In addition, you will be able to monitor the ratings your … Read more

The Army Performance Evaluation Guide

The Army Performance Evaluation Guide

Generating an academic OER through EES for ROTC cadets

The Evaluation Entry System, commonly called EES, is the central digital platform used by the United States Army to build, review and submit performance evaluation reports. For cadets enrolled in the Reserve Officers' Training Corps, the most important document generated through this system is the DA Form 67-9, also called the Academic Officer Evaluation Report. Australian readers who serve alongside United States forces, whether through exchange postings out of Darwin or during joint exercises hosted near Sydney, often encounter the same administrative vocabulary when working with allied units. Knowing how the academic OER is assembled can decide whether a record supports a future promotion board application or triggers rework.

The DA Form 67-9 captures every dimension of a cadet's performance inside the military science classroom and during associated leadership laboratories. Unlike the NCOER or the standard company-grade OER, the Academic OER is written by a professor of military science, frequently a serving Army officer embedded in the host university. For an Australian Defence Force Academy graduate who later pursues a US-affiliated programme, or for an Australian Army Reservist cross-attached to a United States training battalion, the document looks familiar, but the routing logic in EES follows American rules rather than Australian Personnel Service Regulation requirements under the Defence Act 1903.

Access to EES is granted through the Army Knowledge Online identity, and cadets receive a welcome email from Cadet Command during their first term. The interface is browser-based and runs cleanly inside standard Australian internet connections through providers such as Telstra or Optus, provided the user has a current Common Access Card. Once the profile is active, the cadet record appears under the assigned professor of military science, and the academic evaluation can be opened, partially saved and returned to as the observation period unfolds.

Before drafting begins, it is worth taking a few minutes to confirm the evaluation period, the duty description and the senior rater profile. Errors caught at this stage save hours of correction once the form has progressed through the battalion S-1 shop. The platform itself is unforgiving after submission, so careful preparation matters more than speed at this point in the cycle.

Setting up the EES workspace for the academic cycle

Begin by signing in with your CAC-enabled AKO account and confirming the Unit Identification Code matches the PMS detachment printed on your orders. Australian readers who log in from Perth or Melbourne will find that the portal loads identically regardless of geography, though the certificate path may need adjustment on older Defence-issued laptops. Verify that your rater profile is associated with the correct PMS and that the rated soldier block displays your full name, branch and academic year.

The duty description block must be updated each term to reflect current coursework, leadership laboratories and any assigned extra duties such as Ranger Challenge team captain. Paste concise, outcome-focused bullets rather than narrative paragraphs, because the form renders exactly as typed with no rich-text formatting. Keep a saved draft in the local browser cache so your PMS can review the language before you commit to a senior rater. Before the observation window closes, confirm that the chain rater and senior rater blocks display the correct names and ranks.

Drafting the performance narrative block by block

Part IV allows for a narrative assessment of the cadet's potential as a commissioned officer, including leadership, character and communication. Write in the third person, avoid superlatives that cannot be substantiated by recent observation, and reference specific classroom contributions by date. Many raters prefer to keep a running note throughout the semester so the final narrative reads as evidence-based rather than impressionistic.

Part V is reserved for bullet-form comments covering the cadet's performance across the spectrum of leader attributes. Use the same four blocks repeatedly so the format remains familiar to promotion board readers. If you want to understand how this rating eventually affects standing on a promotion board, the promotion points breakdown explains how basic, special and civil categories are calculated during the selection cycle.

Part VI captures the overall rating compared to peers and is one of the most scrutinised blocks during the HRC review. A common error is selecting a rating inconsistent with the language used in Part IV, which often leads to a return by the senior rater. Australian readers should remember that American raters grade more harshly than ADF raters under the Australian Public Service performance framework, so calibrate the rating to the distribution expected by Cadet Command.

Selecting the senior rater profile and narrative

The senior rater is typically the PMS, the head of the department of military science, or a serving field-grade officer serving as battalion S-3. Their profile is selected from a dropdown list populated by the system, and only those with a valid profile record can be chosen. For an academic OER, the senior rater checks the form for consistency, adds their own bullet comments and assigns a senior rater profile block in Part VII.

The senior rater profile must be set before submission, and once locked it cannot be reopened without administrative intervention. Use clear, action-oriented bullets and avoid speculative language about future assignments, because the record will be read years later by a selection board. In cases where the senior rater is also the rater, the system creates a single-block document and simplifies the routing chain. For context on how terminology maps across allied systems, the Bamoko journal notes offer a useful comparison of how evaluation reviews are framed in different national traditions.

Routing the report through PMS and the S-1 shop

After both rater and senior rater blocks are complete, the evaluation is released to the battalion human resources technician for administrative review. The S-1 checks for proper format, correct dates and the presence of a sign-line for the rated soldier to acknowledge review. Australian readers operating in joint environments may find that the S-1 shop applies Army Regulation 623-3 conventions rather than local ADF process maps, so ask for a sample packet before the first submission window.

The acknowledgement step requires the rated cadet to log in with their own CAC and simply confirm that they have seen the report. This is not a concurrence, only acknowledgement, and the form can still be challenged later through a support form if factual errors are discovered after release. Once acknowledged, the evaluation flows forward to the sign-and-submit stage, where final review certifies the record for forwarding through the HQDA sign-and-submit route.

Checklist for a smooth academic OER submission

Attention to small details at the front of the cycle avoids major rework after the form has passed through multiple review layers. The following practical steps keep the packet moving without unnecessary delays.

  • Confirm the UIC and rated name before typing any bullets into the duty description.
  • Update the duty description every term so it reflects current coursework and assigned tasks.
  • Keep a running note on cadet contributions throughout the semester for the Part IV narrative.
  • Match the Part VI overall rating to the language used elsewhere for internal consistency.
  • Have the rated soldier acknowledge the form promptly to avoid stuck packets.
  • Download a PDF copy of the final report after HRC confirmation for personal records.

After the file reaches the AMHRR, advisory pieces on the Astronomy 2009 platform sometimes discuss how evaluation narratives are read by selection boards during the cycle, offering allied observers a useful external lens on the American system.

The Rating Chain Tool User’s Guide

The Rating Chain Tool User's Guide

Whether new or experienced, the Rating Chain Tool User’s Guide can help you get the most from your equipment. This article will cover the key features of the tool as well as provide some frequently asked questions and tips. Exploitability Researchers can quickly determine the potential impact of an exploit using the Exploitability of Rating … Read more

Creating an Evaluation Reporting System

Creating an Evaluation Reporting System

Creating an Evaluation Reporting System is essential to achieving the mission of the HQDA. The purpose of the system is to ensure that evaluations are done on a timely basis and that the information is accurate. The system also helps to ensure that officials who conduct rating activities are eligible to do so. In addition, … Read more

What is the iPERMS website?

The iPERMS website allows soldiers to access their Army EES records. It is an online application that provides administrative information and facilitates evaluation management. It automatically populates with all batches created and submitted in the system, including the number of the batch, the date it was created, and the status. The process also requires a … Read more

How Do I Find My Military ID Number?

The military ID card has a unique identification number that you can use to access various services and places. It is issued to active duty service members, National Guard members, civilian employees of the Defense Department, and some contractors. You must have this card to access certain installations, buildings, and secured computer networks. Regardless of … Read more

How Do I View My ERB?

You can check your promotion points online by viewing your Enlisted Record Brief. This is your official military file. You can access it through the Human Resources Command’s iPERMS website, or you can print it from your S1. This document contains the information you need to calculate your promotion points. In order to view your … Read more

Ezoic report this ad