Finding the Correct Rater Profile for Nonselection Consideration
A nonselection consideration can depend on whether an evaluation was prepared, routed and submitted under the correct rating relationship. For Army personnel using the Evaluation Entry System (EES), the relevant rater profile is linked to the rating chain, report type and assessment period—not simply to the person who happens to supervise the soldier day to day.
This guide explains how to identify the right profile, check the administrative trail and address discrepancies before they affect a board review or reconsideration request. It is general information for soldiers and Army staff, not an official Army directive, and current HRC, unit S1 and board instructions should take priority.
What The Rater Profile Represents
A rater profile is associated with the senior rater’s evaluation history and the population against which reports are compared. For an NCOER or OER, the correct profile normally follows the approved rating chain, duty position and applicable evaluation rules. A profile selected merely because it appears in a search result may be the wrong one.
The key distinction is between the evaluator, the rating relationship and the profile owner. A rater or senior rater may have several roles, commands or reporting periods in EES. The correct entry should match the report being considered, including the rated soldier, assigned organisation, duty dates and evaluation type.
Start With The Approved Rating Chain
Before searching for a profile, obtain the approved support form, evaluation notification, signed report or other official paperwork showing the rating chain. Compare the rater, intermediate rater where applicable, senior rater and reviewer against the unit’s records. The Army’s requirements can vary by evaluation type and status, so assumptions based on a previous report can be unsafe.
The rater chain guide can help clarify how the command relationship is represented in EES. If the evaluator changed command during the period, check which authority covered the relevant dates rather than selecting the person with the most recent job title.
Match Dates, Grade And Report Type
Use the evaluation period as the primary filter. A senior rater’s profile may contain several completed reports, and the profile that looks current may not apply to the report connected with nonselection consideration. Confirm the rated soldier’s grade, component, duty position, organisation and the report’s “from” and “to” dates.
Also check whether the document is an NCOER, OER, AER or another evaluation product. AER processing, temporary duty, a change of rater, relief for cause or a change in duty assignment can produce different administrative requirements. If a soldier served in Brisbane, Perth or another location while remaining under a U.S. Army chain of command, the Australian location itself does not replace the official rating relationship.
Check Profile History And Submission Evidence
A profile search should be supported by evidence from EES, the unit administrator and the personnel record. Save relevant screenshots or transaction details, but avoid storing sensitive files on a shared computer or sending personally identifying information through ordinary email. CAC access, local permissions and browser settings can affect what an individual sees.
Review the report’s status, signature sequence, corrections and submission date. A profile can appear valid while the underlying report is missing a required signature, routed to the wrong reviewer or associated with an incorrect organisation. The promotion worksheet guide is useful when checking whether evaluation information has flowed into related personnel and promotion records.
Consider Australian Working Conditions
Australian-based soldiers often manage U.S. Army administration across a different working week, time zone and public-holiday calendar. A unit in Sydney or Melbourne may be coordinating with personnel in the continental United States, while Queensland and Western Australia operate on different local times. Allow enough time for S1 review, system access and corrections before a board deadline.
Everyday practices also matter. Do not use a café Wi-Fi network in Adelaide or a public computer at a library to access EES or upload records. Keep CAC credentials private, use an approved device and follow applicable U.S. Army cybersecurity rules. Australia’s Privacy Act 1988 and workplace privacy expectations reinforce the need to limit unnecessary disclosure, although Army information systems remain governed by their own authorised procedures.
Personal browsing should stay separate from official administrative work. For example, opening a motorcycle safety resource or another unrelated website on a government device can create avoidable security and audit concerns. The issue is not the subject of the website; it is the separation of personal activity from protected personnel transactions.
Practical Checks Before Submission
Use a short verification process before accepting the profile as correct. It should confirm both the administrative relationship and the evidence available if a nonselection review later questions the report.
- Compare the profile owner with the signed senior rater or reviewing official.
- Match the report type, grade, organisation and evaluation dates.
- Confirm that the rating chain was valid for the entire relevant period.
- Check EES status, signatures, corrections and submission history.
- Ask the unit S1 or designated administrator to validate unusual entries.
- Keep a secure record of supporting documents and transaction dates.
- Follow the current board, HRC and Army guidance for reconsideration.
If the profile is unclear, pause the submission rather than selecting the closest-looking record. A written explanation from the S1, rating official or authorised administrator can be more useful than an unsupported assumption, particularly when the case involves a change of command, missing evaluation or disputed duty dates.
Escalating A Suspected Profile Error
When a profile appears wrong, identify the exact discrepancy: incorrect senior rater, wrong organisation, mismatched dates, missing report or unauthorised relationship. Provide the supporting document and explain how the error could affect the evaluation or nonselection consideration. Keep the wording factual and avoid alleging misconduct unless the evidence supports that claim.
Start with the unit S1, evaluation administrator or chain of command, then use the official escalation route specified in the current policy or board notice. A service member stationed in Canberra, Townsville or elsewhere in Australia may need to coordinate across U.S. and Australian business hours, so record each contact, response and deadline.
Do not rely on unofficial websites to override an Army personnel record. General sites, including a separate reference site, may be useful for broad background but cannot authenticate a rater profile or correct an EES transaction. The authoritative answer should come from the authorised Army system, the responsible personnel office and the current instructions governing the review.